Skip to content
← All reflections

When letting go is an act of love

There are decisions no family ever feels ready to make.

You sit beside someone you love. Machines are helping keep them alive. The medical team explains what is happening, what treatment can accomplish, and what their body may no longer be able to do.

You hear the words, but your heart keeps asking:

What if they get better? What if we wait another day? How can we possibly say goodbye?

You don’t want to give up. You also don’t want someone you love to endure more suffering.

Both feelings come from a heart that wishes things could be different.

This past weekend, I spent time with a family facing this heartbreaking reality. They weren’t ready to say goodbye. Their loved one’s body was weak and breaking down. They were coming to the painful realization that honoring this person’s wishes meant accepting a goodbye they did not want.

This family didn’t share my beliefs. But sitting together, we shared something deeply human: love for family, the fear of loss, and the desire to do right by someone who matters to us.

I was reminded how hard it can be to fulfill a loved one’s wishes when doing so feels like giving up on them.

Sometimes this is what love asks of us—to honor what someone wanted while our own hearts are still pleading for more time.

Understanding doesn’t make it easy.

You may understand what the doctors are saying and still feel responsible for what happens next.

Did we decide too soon? Should we have waited? Did they know how much we loved them?

Those questions can follow you home. They can surface in the middle of the night or when everything gets quiet.

Feeling guilty doesn’t necessarily mean you did something wrong. Sometimes it reveals how desperately you wanted an outcome you could not make happen.

You wanted them to get well. You wanted to bring them home. You wanted another conversation, another holiday, another ordinary day together.

Of course you did.

When life support is withdrawn, care still continues. Comfort matters. Relief from distress matters. Their dignity matters.

And your presence matters.

There may still be a hand to hold, words to speak, or silence to share. Love is still there, even when the focus of care changes.

Honoring a loved one’s wishes can be a deeply difficult act of devotion. You can believe you are honoring them and wish with everything in you that you didn’t have to make this decision.

They didn’t fail. Neither did you.

We often describe illness as a battle. Someone “fought a good fight.” When they die, we sometimes say they “lost the fight.”

I understand those words. We want to honor their courage through treatments, setbacks, pain, and uncertainty.

But I wonder what those words can leave a family carrying.

Did they stop fighting? Did we stop fighting for them? Could we have done more?

A body reaching its limits is not a personal failure. Death does not erase someone’s courage or mean they lacked determination, faith, or a reason to live.

And accepting that their body is dying does not mean you have stopped loving them.

What comes after goodbye?

Is there life after death? Will we see one another again? Is there something more? Or is this the end?

For some, faith offers a steady hope. For others, there are questions, doubts, or no settled belief at all. Even people with deep faith may find themselves wrestling beside a hospital bed.

As a pastor and chaplain, I bring my own faith and hope into these moments. I also know that the person sitting beside me may see things differently.

You don’t have to share my beliefs for your grief to matter. You don’t have to settle every question about what comes next before you can be supported in what you are facing now.

I think of my friends who are rabbis, priests, counselors, and caregivers—people of faith and people with no religious belief. I am grateful for those who enter these tender places with compassion, willing to listen without needing to have an answer for everything.

Sometimes we need someone who will simply stay. Someone who can hear our questions, sit with our tears, and make room for what we cannot yet put into words.

Grief is heavy enough without shame.

Perhaps a place to begin is allowing yourself to tell the whole truth:

“I wanted more time.”

“I wanted their suffering to end.”

“I wanted to honor their wishes.”

“I wish I had never had to make this decision.”

All of those things can be true.

You can feel relief that suffering has ended and still ache for one more conversation. You can believe you honored their wishes and still feel heartbroken about how it happened.

Relief does not diminish your love. Tears do not prove you made the wrong decision.

Sometimes it helps to talk through what happened with the medical team, a bereavement counselor, a chaplain, or someone you trust. You may need to tell the story more than once. You deserve someone who will listen without rushing you toward closure.

Grief doesn’t operate on a timeline.

How will I carry their life with me?

That question may come later. At first, getting through the day may be enough.

In time, honoring them might mean telling their stories, making their favorite meal, continuing a tradition, or passing along something they taught you.

It might mean offering someone the kindness they offered you. Finding courage in their example. Caring for a person or cause that mattered to them.

You don’t have to make someone perfect to honor them. Every life is complicated. You can remember honestly and carry forward what was good.

Moving forward doesn’t mean forgetting. There can be room for new joy and new experiences alongside the love you will always have for them.

Their influence can continue in the choices you make, the people you care for, and the stories the next generation will hear.

After so much attention to the circumstances of their death, you deserve room to remember the whole of their life.

A place to remember. Someone to walk with you.

A memorial can help make that room. We gather to acknowledge the loss, but also to remember the person—their laughter, their familiar ways, the relationships they built, and the difference they made.

As a memorial celebrant, I consider it a privilege to help families tell those stories and create a gathering that reflects the person they love. That begins with listening to who they were, what mattered to them, and what matters to those who are grieving.

Sometimes the need is for a meaningful goodbye. Sometimes it is for support afterward, when the gathering is over and the quiet feels different. Sometimes it is both.

If you are looking for someone to help honor your loved one, or need support as you begin to process the loss, I welcome the conversation. Whatever your beliefs, whatever questions you carry, there is room for your story.

Your relationship was so much more than a medical decision. Their life was so much more than its final hours.

You are allowed to grieve deeply, remember honestly, and carry their love forward—without putting yourself on trial for a goodbye you never wanted.

— Steve Snook

Reach out, at your pace.

You don’t need to know what to say. A short note is enough. I respond as quickly as I can, day or night.

Email ssnook57@icloud.com